] NEWS: Clark fails leadership test - Rt Hon John Key
News release

2 Comments
31 October 2007
NEWS: Clark fails leadership test

Helen Clark has failed to show leadership by rewarding Trevor Mallard instead of punishing him for his behaviour in Parliament, says National Party Leader John Key.

"Instead of demoting him, she has effectively given him a portfolio promotion by handing him three influential new responsibilities - in addition to retaining his SOEs and Associate Finance roles.

"No fair minded Kiwi would view Trevor Mallard's portfolio promotion as an exercise in caucus discipline.

"It also makes a mockery of Helen Clark's claim that Mr Mallard is suffering from stress.  Surely giving him more responsibilities and workload adds to his stress, especially in an area like Environment which is supposedly central to Labour's re-election plans.

"The reshuffle is a lame exercise in recycling, not renewal.

"The same people are still in charge – Helen Clark and Michael Cullen. They are the same tired old faces singing the same tired old songs.

"I note that Labour's master strategist, Pete Hodgson, has lost Health, which is an admission of failure in a portfolio that has had billions thrown at it over the past nine years for seemingly little result."


Trackbacks

No Trackbacks

Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)

#1 - Liam McKay 2007-10-31 15:23 - (Reply)

Well if this isn't a prime example of the pot calling the kettle black! The last time I checked National still had a whole swag of tired faces sitting in its ranks. The same tired faces who ruined the country back in the 90s and then got booted out for doing so. What is even more laughable is that you, Mr Key, gave Bill English the role of deputy leader - the same guy who delivered National their worst ever election result. If you want to talk about tired faces, bad decisions and poor leadership John Key, look no further than your own front bench. And by the way, what exactly is a "fair minded kiwi"?

#2 - M. L Kedzlie 2007-10-31 16:47 - (Reply)

I beg to differ. Those so called tired old faces had to clean up the countries balance sheet after the last Labour Government was reckless with tax payers money. A National Government which had to make hard choices about getting inflation down from 17% to under 3% so that New Zealanders would have a chance to economically prosper. Bill Birch sorted out the massive distortions in our nations balance sheet. A Government who put more New Zealanders into real productive jobs than the previous and currrent Labour Government. A Government which did not take more tax than it needed. A Government that did more for Maori hopes and apirations in the single year of 1995 with treaty claims under Jim Bolgers leadership that what Labour have done in the last eight years. Mistakes were made? Yes, all Governments do, but at least that pragmatism of National has the flexibility to learn from them unlike the dogmatic inflexibility of Labour. Under Labour things have got worse not better. New Zealand in the mid 1990's was doing better than Australia. Only a moronic clown would contend that today. Thats why New Zealanders are leaving in droves. They want a comfortable life, not an existence in a state of serfdom. If I remember the Helen Clark and Michael Cullen duo did not do that well in the 1996 Election and she was alot older and had been in parliament a lot longer than when a young Bill English tried out for the job. But, I dont want to dwell on the past - that is Labour's territory. They are the past in all its tenses as was revealed in its new Cabinet line up today. An old rotation policy? An old rotation policy using the injured list to replace the tired and retired list more like it.


Add Comment

E-Mail addresses will not be displayed and will only be used for E-Mail notifications

To prevent automated Bots from commentspamming, please enter the string you see in the image below in the appropriate input box. Your comment will only be submitted if the strings match. Please ensure that your browser supports and accepts cookies, or your comment cannot be verified correctly.
CAPTCHA

 
Submitted comments will be subject to moderation before being displayed.